Annuities, without the parts that get glossed over
An annuity is a contract with an insurance company: you hand over money now, and it pays you back on defined terms later. That trade can be genuinely useful for turning savings into income you cannot outlive. It is also the product where the terms that matter most — surrender periods, caps, fees, what is guaranteed and what is illustrated — are the ones explained last. Here they are first.
What we go through
- What each contract type actually does: fixed, fixed indexed, variable, immediate and deferred
- Separating what is contractually guaranteed from what an illustration merely projects
- Surrender periods: how long your money is committed and what leaving early costs
- The fee layers — and which ones are disclosed only if you ask
- How an annuity fits, or does not fit, alongside the rest of your retirement income
Questions worth having answered
- What is an annuity, in plain terms?
- It is a contract with an insurance company. You pay in, either as a lump sum or over time, and in exchange the company agrees to pay you back under agreed terms — either starting almost immediately, which is an immediate annuity, or at some point in the future, which is a deferred annuity. The reason people use them is that an insurer can promise income for as long as you live, which no ordinary investment account can do. The reason to read carefully is that you are trading away access to that money and taking on the insurer's promise, so the terms and the financial strength of the company behind them are the product.
- What is the difference between fixed, indexed and variable?
- They differ in who carries the investment risk. A fixed annuity credits a stated rate of interest — predictable, and the insurer carries the risk. A variable annuity invests in market subaccounts you choose, so the value rises and falls with those markets and you carry the risk, usually with the highest fee layer of the three. A fixed indexed annuity sits between them: the credited return is linked to an index but is not an investment in it, with the downside typically limited and the upside limited too, by caps, participation rates or spreads that the insurer can often adjust within contractual limits. That last point is the one most often missed — an indexed contract does not pay the index return, and the mechanism that decides what it does pay is worth reading before signing.
- What does a surrender period actually cost me?
- A surrender period is the number of years your money is committed, commonly somewhere between three and ten depending on the contract. Withdraw more than the contract permits during that window and the insurer keeps a surrender charge, usually a percentage that steps down each year. Most contracts allow a limited penalty-free withdrawal annually, often around a tenth of the value, and taking money out before age fifty-nine and a half can carry a tax penalty on top, separate from anything the insurer charges. The practical test before committing: if you needed a significant part of this money three years from now, what would it cost to get it, and could you live with that answer?
- What should I ask before I sign anything?
- Six questions, and the answers should be in the contract rather than in a brochure. What exactly is guaranteed, in writing, as opposed to illustrated or projected. What are all the fees, including rider charges and any annual contract fee. How long is the surrender period and what is the charge in each year of it. How much can I withdraw each year without penalty. If it is indexed, what are the caps, participation rates or spreads, and can the insurer change them later. And what is the financial strength rating of the company making the promise. If any answer is difficult to obtain in writing, treat that as information about the product.
Still not sure where you stand?
That is the normal starting point, and it is the easiest thing to fix. Tell me roughly what prompted you to look and we will work out what you actually need before discussing any product.
Get in touch